The crossword has a radical history. A puzzle veteran explores why

In August, New York City mayoral campaigner Zohran Mamdani hosted a citywide scavenger hunt, inviting voters to scour the boroughs successful hunt of historical governmental sites. (Grand prize: a container of chips.) Clues for it were written by seasoned puzzle shaper Natan Last, who has agelong endorsed the thought that puzzles astatine their champion blend politics, assemblage and a nerdy bully time.

If you missed the hunt, Last’s book, “Across the Universe,” delivers akin pleasures. Though its subtitle — “The Past, Present, and Future of the Crossword Puzzle” — suggests a past tome, Last approaches the taxable essayistically. Crosswords, for him, are arguments connected behalf of things: of what qualifies arsenic “common knowledge,” of what relation puzzles should play successful informing a citizenry, of however wordplay and slang snake into the mainstream. “The crossword is simply a uniquely capacious artifact acceptable to sorb and recast immoderate group’s predilections and passions into puzzle form,” helium writes.

That whitethorn look similar making excessively overmuch retired of an mundane diversion. But arsenic Last points out, crosswords person agelong been a miniature mentation of America’s larger civilization wars. Crosswords’ popularity exploded successful the 1920s successful assorted newspapers; Ernie Bushmiller, cartoonist of “Nancy” fame, exploited the “crossword craze” successful a portion called “Cross Word Cal.” But killjoys swiftly arrived to disregard it arsenic paleolithic encephalon rot. The New York Times, present the best-known purveyor of crosswords, thought the puzzle beneath it, and didn’t connection 1 until 1941. (“The past big successful the newsroom,” Last smirks.)

(Pantheon)

The New York Times’ crossword is synonymous with its existent editor, Will Shortz, who gave the puzzle a refresh successful the 1990s, jettisoning world jargon and obscurities successful favour of layered puns and pop-culture references. Last recalls moving arsenic Shortz’s intern successful 2009 and loving the experience. But Last is besides the constituent of the spear among constructors who importune there’s plentifulness of country for improvement: tokenized taste terms, deficiency of sex parity among constructors, treble standards (“erotica” is acceptable, but “gay erotica” isn’t?), a constrictive presumption of what readers cognize oregon volition accept. “The barroom is connected the floor,” USA Today crossword exertion Erik Agard tells Last.

Last’s nationalist statements connected this subject, helium writes, are often met with oculus rolls: “Oh, truthful present the crossword puzzle needs to beryllium woke?” But that precocious dudgeon, helium notes, is “as bully a impervious arsenic immoderate that it’s not conscionable a puzzle.” Not for the solvers helium speaks to, who usage their puzzle routines arsenic calming influences oregon mementos of relationships. Not for constructors similar India-born Mangesh Ghogre, who came to the U.S. connected an H-1B visa to marque puzzles and who cleverly works Indian themes into his grids. And surely not for institutions similar the New York Times, which has made games a nett halfway successful a quality manufacture that’s often hemorrhaging cash.

Last’s scope and quality assistance merchantability the value of the crossword, past and now. Still, its deficiency of a nonstop throughline tin beryllium frustrating. Like a peculiarly manic solver, helium attacks the taxable successful an across-and-down fashion, present contemplating the interaction of AI connected the game, determination considering what relation crossword-style wordplay had connected Modernist writers similar T.S. Eliot and Gertrude Stein, present contemplating the 1920s crossword craze, present skipping to its 2020s COVID-prompted renaissance. It’s each relevant, and Last is simply a agleam and witty usher done each of it. He demands a definite comfortableness level with disorientation, though.

Still, that’s benignant of the point: For him, puzzles should motivate solvers to beryllium much than half-thinking container fillers. Instead, we should beryllium comfy learning caller ideas done the puzzle. Mamdani’s scavenger hunt didn’t play a large relation successful his eventual predetermination to the mayorship successful October; it astir apt didn’t adjacent play a tiny one. But it spoke to the concepts of play, astonishment and diverseness that the crossword astatine its champion represents for Last. Maybe you don’t person contiguous callback connected the connection “Haudenosaunee” (the Native sanction for the Iroquois Confederacy), but what’s truthful atrocious astir a crossword puzzle introducing you to it? Like each different conception of the paper, the crossword tin bring the news. It tin evoke — and signifier — a culture.